by Chris McDonnell
I recently received an email from a friend in which he concluded with the line: “Have a less ascetic Lent but a more thoughtful one.”
That phrase has been rumbling round my mind since I first read it. Two words, and their meaning, are key, ‘ascetic’ and ‘thoughtful.’ What do they mean? What are the implications for our experience in Lent? How should we react?
There is a long history, in many religious traditions, of the ascetic way of life, the voluntary acceptance of personal deprivation for a higher goal. This can be mild in form, whether it be a matter of diet, fasting or a shorter time spent in sleep, all practiced as means to an end. Or it might be extreme, involving physical discomfort and real challenge over the short or longer term.
Is it the case that underlying all ascetic practice is the notion that the goal of reaching God comes through our personal suffering? I find some difficulty with that, even though in its ultimate form, martyrdom, it indicates a greater love that involves the greater sacrifice.
So in the time of Lent, the giving up of something, with whatever discomfort or inconvenience that causes, has been seen as beneficial to the Christian life, a way of moving forward, a stripping away of unnecessary clutter.
Maybe that is all well and good, but what about that other word in my friend’s e-mail, ‘thoughtful’? There is here the implication of reflection, the necessary pause that gives opportunity to ask questions. This is missing for so many people, they never have time to pause, to reflect, to be thoughtful. A priest here in UK, who was ordained before the Council, often argues that for many priests today, they live such busy, task-orientated lives that they have little time to be thoughtful, to read and to reflect on the considered writings of others. So their growth is restricted, there is little to replenish the worn personal fabric of their overcrowded lives. They gradually lose their vitality and enthusiasm diminishes.
There is a strong argument therefore for Lent to be the ‘pause time’ for reflection, for thoughtfulness, for personal care and renewal. That time has to be created, carefully set aside and protected from intrusion.
The Cistercian, John Eudes Bamberger, said this in conversation with Henri Nouwen, quoted in the Genesee diary:
Time has to be set aside for regular prayer, time made so that life revolves and evolves round our time with the Lord. Set a time that is reasonable, and once it is set, stick to it all costs. Make it your most important task. Let everyone know that this is the only thing you will not change, and pray at that time.
Maybe here is the crux of a Lenten resolution. Take one essential aspect of prayer to be a thoughtful Christian reflection on our individual circumstance and a wish to have a greater understanding of God, a willingness to listen, and there it is. Hard to do, ascetic is one sense, the need to stick to it, but thoughtful in the time we set aside and how we use it, how it might change us.
Rabbi Lionel Blue, speaking on BBC Radio 4 back in February 2002, concluded his talk with these words:
“I have found that prayer doesn’t change the cosmos but it does change me.”
Chris McDonnell is a regular reader and commenter at Pray Tell Blog.