R.I.P. Fr. Paul Nienaber, S.J.

With a heavy heart but full of hope in the power of Christ’s Resurrection, I would like to share with the readers of Pray Tell the news of the recent death of Fr. Paul Nienaber, S.J., a contemporary hymn text writer. He would have had witty yet insightful remarks to make over the fact that he entered into eternal life on 31 October 2020. (My guess is that he would have seen the compatibility of both the “secular” Halloween festival in which we laugh at the “ghoulies and ghosties,” confident that death has been defeated, and the “sacred” festival, with its promise of welcoming his voice to the choirs of heaven on the Eve of All Saints.)

He died at the age of 65, having served as a Jesuit for 30 years. He combined in his person and work a most amazing yoking of scientific exploration and artistic creativity. I often thought that in that yoking he followed the path of another Jesuit, Pere Pierre Teilhard de Chardain, S.J., noted paleontologist and poet of a Christ-centered evolving universe.

As a scientist, he earned a doctorate in physics from the University of Illinois at Champaign, IL in 1988, the same year he entered the Society of Jesus. (According to my memories, I first met Paul around that time when I gave a liturgical music workshop at the Newman Center at Champaign-Urbana, where he was working with the music ministry there.) During his regency, Paul was visiting professor of physics at Xavier University from 1992-1995. After ordination to the priesthood in 1999, he worked at Fermilab (Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory) in Batavia, IL, serving full-time there from 2000-2001 and again from 2002-2004. He then continued part-time at Fermilab while serving in various academic positions at Marquette University (1999-2000), the College of the Holy Cross (2001-2002), eventually settling at St. Mary’s University of Minnesota in Winona (2004-2019). From 2009-2019, Paul was an associate professor of physics and the chair of the physics department at St. Mary’s.

As a wordsmith, Paul crafted both memorable homilies and exquisite hymn texts. In 2015, World Library Publications brought out a collection of 28 of his hymn texts set by a variety of composers entitled Arise, O Church! Texts for Sung Prayer by Paul Nienaber, S.J. In that collection, I had the honor of setting his metrical version of Psalm 63 “For You I Long” with a CMD hymn tune I called ANCHORAGE, an image taken from the final verse of his text. Paul also contributed to another World Library Publications collection entitled Be Forever Praised! Psalms, Hymns, and Spiritual Songs. (WLP is now a subsidiary of GIA Publications, which continues to make Paul’s hymn-texts available.)

In December of 2019, Paul took up residence at the Colombiere Center in Missouri as his health was failing. Both because of his frailty and because the COVID-19 pandemic made travel difficult, we connected by phone every couple of months. I regret that we played “telephone tag” for the last few weeks of his life but never made contact then. Paul’s funeral was celebrated on 6 November 2020 at Colombiere Center and through the kindness of the Jesuit community there I was able to attend virtually via livestreaming. At his funeral, the preacher (whom I believe was Fr. Robert Scullin, S.J., the superior of the community there) summed up Paul’s three great loves as his Jesuit priesthood, his ability to arouse wonder in his students, and his love of worship, especially in the Church’s song. I can testify to the truth of this insight.

I think it is only fair that Paul should have the last word in this memorial tribute. I don’t know if he was thinking of himself when he wrote “A New Passover,” but I do know he believed with all his heart in the promise of the Resurrection evoked in these words:

When earth’s banquets all have ended,
when we reach those farther shores
where the songs of saints are blended
with the angels’ blissful scores,
at the wedding table seated,
hosted by our great High Priest,
sin forgiven, death defeated-
all are welcomed to the feast.

(Fr. Jan) Michael Joncas
University of St. Thomas
6 November 2020


  1. Thank you for this wonderful post. I had occasion to talk with Fr. Paul concerning a comment that we turned into a post here at Pray Tell (on the ministry of cantors) and was very impressed with his pastoral insight and thoughtful perspective on ministry.


    I am sorry to hear of his untimely death, and grateful to know more about his contributions and character. May he rest in peace, and may all who mourn his passing be comforted.

  2. Michael – We have spoken on numerous occasions about our connection to Paul. He was a part of my family spending 30 plus years of holidays with us, singing at our wedding, being Godfather to my son, marrying nephews and nieces, baptizing their children. Christmas Day will not be the same for us without him. He was more than my friend, he was my brother and I and his surrogate family were devastated by his loss. Thank you so much for this remembrance. The relationship that the two of you had meant the world to him and he spoke of you often. I would love to talk to you. PrayTellBlog – I give you my permission to share my email with Fr. Joncas. May Herr, Professor, Dr., Uncle, Fr. Paul Rest In Peace and Rise in Glory!

  3. I got to know Paul in Winona and treasure our friendship. He was always interesting to talk to and I learned much from him. May he rest in peace.

  4. Thank you. Beautifully written. You’ve captured him so well and in the eloquent style that befits him. He was a dear friend since meeting at the U of I Champaign-Urbana around 1979. I will miss him.

  5. Thank you so much for this post. I had the pleasure of knowing Paul first as his editor, then becoming both colleagues and friends. I had the same thought about what his observation may have been when he passed on October 31st!

  6. Thank you for this beautiful, authentic tribute to my friend Paul – brilliant, creative, but mostly memorably witty. I am grateful that he is not suffering and now released from his earthly body that was limiting his ability to do all the things that “Paul does” ha ha.
    May he inspire each of us from above!
    Donna Scheppe – a choir friend from St. John Newman Center in Champaign

  7. Respectful farewell to Fr. Paul. Eternal rest grant unto him O Lord and let your perpetual light shine upon the departed soul.

  8. I hardly knew Fr. Paul but did love to hear the homilies he preached during the summers he said Masses at St. Scholastica here in Woodridge, IL. He could really relate the gospels to our every day living and I still remember some of his words that I try to live today. May the Divine Mercy of Jesus embrace him and grant him eternal happiness.

    1. Thank you Michael for your wonderful tribute of Paul Nienaber…not a simple task for such a complex man! I attended the U of I in the early years with Paul. At the St. John’s Newman Center, I was one of the guitarists in the choir Paul was in. Paul very gifted yet so conflicted between physics, music and the call to serve his faith! I believe the workshop you mentioned where you met Paul may have been in 1981 at St. Pat’s in Urbana Il. For the final workshop liturgy, Paul was extremely honored to sing and cantor with you…and I got to play guitar with you…while Elaine Rendler was so loud she literally blew us all away on organ (lol)! I also remember how thrilled Paul was when you and he began corresponding about some of his earliest texts! Paul was a good friend and Godfather to our oldest daughter (who now teaches choir at the National Cathedral School). We have been in the Albany NY area for nearly 40 years and sadly the distance came between us and we have not stayed in contact with him. Nonetheless, I will never forget the example Paul gave us in how to meld our faith and our music talents together.
      Paul, your life and your friendship continue to bear fruit in all of us and will never be forgotten. Hallelujah, the great strife is over. Lift up your wings and fly!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *